Manhattan’s Pizza Trail: Uncover the Best Slices in Each Neighborhood

A Pizza for Every Preference.

Finding a great slice of pizza is practically a rite of passage for Manhattanites and visitors alike. It seems like there’s an unlimited number of options to go for in the city. Everyone will tell you they have the “best” pizza recommendation but true locals know that what it really comes down to (like with most things in life) is personal preference – whether it be the classic thin crust foldable slice or the smoky char of a neapolitan – the “best” pizza really is within the mouth of the beholder.

That’s why we’ve devised this compendium of where to go based on ten distinct neighborhoods in Manhattan. We’ve waded through the limitless number of options so you don’t have to. In our list, you’ll find there’s a slice to satisfy every craving and palate; and don’t forget – the quest for the perfect slice is an adventure unto itself.

1. Lower East Side

• Scarr’s Pizza
  • 35 Orchard St (map)
• Una Pizza Napoletana
  • 175 Orchard St (map)
• Prince Street Pizza
  • 27 Prince St (map)

2. East Village

• Joe’s Pizza
  • 150 E 14th St (map)
• Motorino Pizza
  • 349 E 12th St (map)

3. Greenwich Village

• Bleeker Street Pizza
  • 69 7th Ave S (map)
• Joe’s
  • 7 Carmine St (map)

4. Soho

• Arturo’s
  • 106 W Houston St (map)
• Famous Ben’s Pizza
  • 177 Spring St (map)

5. Chelsea

• Artichoke Basille’s Pizza
  • 114 10th Ave (map)
• New York Pizza Supreme
  • 413 8th Ave (map)
• Don Giovanni
  • 214 10th Ave (map)
• Gotham Pizza
  • 144 9th Ave (map)

6. Tribeca

• Nolita Pizza
  • (map)
• Lucia Pizza Of SoHo
  • (map)

7. Midtown

• Joe’s Pizza Broadway
  • 1435 Broadway (map)
• Patsy’s Pizzeria
  • 801 2nd Ave (map)
• Vezzo NYC Thin Crust Pizza
  • 178 Lexington Ave (map)

8. Upper East Side

• San Matteo Pizzeria e Cucina
  • 1559 2nd Ave (map)
• Italian Village Pizza
  • 1494 1st Ave (map)
• Williamsburg Pizza Upper East Side
  • 1617 2nd Ave (map)

9. Upper West Side

• Celeste
  • 502 Amsterdam Ave (map)
• Sal & Carmine
  • 2671 Broadway (map)
• Made In New York Pizza
  • 421 Amsterdam Ave (map)

10. Harlem

• Armonie
  • 1649 Park Ave (map)
• Dado’s Pizza and Taproom Harlem
  • 341 St Nicholas Ave (map)
• Sottocasa
  • 227 Malcolm X Blvd (map)